The hammerspur is checkered and measures 0.38 inch wide. Let the new gun owners have their space in time. Up until this time, Magnum had been reserved for the larger N-frame Smiths. Let me start by saying, the new Classic model, while looking to the original 19, is a different pistol from yesteryear. Bought a S&W model 19 as a on Duty revolver in 1970. Hand fitting is non-existent. I recently switched from carrying a 9mm Colt LW 1911 Commander to a 4 Smith & Wesson Model 19-4 .357 Magnum in a Galco Combat Master holster on a quality, heavy 1/2 leather belt. I sure wish that I could get a new Ruger GP-100 in .357 Magnum with a 5-inch barrel. The Classic 19 is a great addition to the Smith & Wesson line. Check Price . 244.99 . The most accurate .357 Magnum load was the Winchester 125-grain Defender ammo. My new from the factory custom shop model 41 pistol is a nightmare. Theres no doubt about it, the S&W K-Frame is legendary. Smith & Wesson Model 69, 4.25" Barrel, 44 Magnum . I am surprised with precision standards as high as you seem to have you did not bother to try the ammo that bullseye comp shooters use to leg out in Distinguish Revolver division that requires ub 2 groups @ 50 yards.. But in all fairness, you need to compare that snubby to a 3 or shorter 9 mm. The red ramp Baughman-style front sight is pinned into the barrel shroud. I never cared for the way the magnum grips spread my fingers at the base of the grip and I wear a size 10.5 surgical glove! The Model 19 is great for those just learning to shoot a revolver, as well as for a daily carry, personal defense pistol. Replace the spring of the magazine. Contrast all that with a semi-auto pistol. S&W's 686 PC is a competition-class thoroughbred for discerning wheelgun addicts. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. At any rate, you dont have to be one of the purists he mentioned to have an aversion to buying products that include a you WILL bend the knee feature. COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. I just couldnt get the cylinder to turn fast enough. But thats not all the shooting I did with the new Model 19. I will also say this: Kimbers revolvers are EXTREMELY close to S&W K-frames when it comes to double action trigger pull out of the box. Always favored the bright blued over the nickel plated. Drop in the parts and send it out the door. Last night I primed 400 38 special cases with my last win smalls. The cost has risen substantially, as more and more people recognize a classic, and pay for the quality. S&W, please stop putting junk parts in your otherwise nice guns. Having had. That little hole above the cylinder release is my main turn off with S&W revolvers. As an aside, I hada conversationabout this gunwith ayounger but experienced shooter. That said, Berettas are what you show your freinds, Glocks are what you show your enemies! . I carried a Smith & Wesson J-frame for a couple of decades, and still carry a Model 29 when Ihunt. Failure to feed, Failure to eject, Stove Piping. The second significant difference is that the diameter of the barrel is thicker than the older guns. We are all showing our age here when complaining about the Hillary Hole, MIM parts, shrouded barrels. Its just about perfect for personal protection, and it makes a darn good trail gun, too. The weight makes up for the 4.0-inch length. I usually head right to the range with a pistol. Except When It Is, SHOT Show: Smith & Wesson Gets Into 5.7 With the New M&P5.7 Pistol, SHOT Show: Digging Into the Really New RIA 5.0 9mm Pistol, SHOT Show: The GLOCK 47 9mm Pistol Is Finally Available For Everyone, http://ruger.com/products/gp100/specSheets/1740.html. Stainless steel contains chromium, which resists the leeching, and this makes stainless a better gun steel, in my opinion. loads are not +p but just standard full pressure loads which every revolver is proofed to 130%. Models 10 and 64 have a heavy barrel and fixed sights while the Model 67 adds an adjustable rear sight and red ramp front sight. the .357 Magnum offers relatively little stopping power improvement over the 9mm+P.. If you ever get into Grizzly territory youll want the .45. Note: The 19-3 revolver with 357 magnum self defense loads is always on my hip while hunting, just in case I run into an overly aggressive (or hungry) bear that wants to mess with me. Now both the P09 and VP9 are capable of 1 groups @ 25 but no way do they run sub 2 with a bunch of various SD or other loads. They will fix it and pay shipping. Since the TTAG editors cut my last comment, Ill be nicer this time. Finally, they are solid you can rap them with your hand or shake them and nothing rattles or shimmies. Yep, the model 19 is a beautiful piece but I wont buy a revolver with a built-in lock. You just can't ask for more in a revolver. If the lock is intended to keep children from firing the gun, this may lead to irresponsible leaving the locked gun out. How the trigger pulls through the entire cycle and that pulls effect on the sights is ultimately what matters, not what a scale says. I ordered the 4.25-inch-barreled Classic revolver for my shooting review. If the pistol has a striker, you cannot feel anything as you pull the trigger other than taking up the often considerable slack and spring tension. No matter, I own a Model 586 in bought in 1992 that still have along with the 29 and a 657. My most accurate load was the Black Hills .38 Special 148-grain SWC ammo, and it averaged 2.47 inches for five, five-shot groups. Ruger Lcp . But it would take many, many thousands of rounds of the lighter stuff to destroy that 19 so I wouldnt bother with .38s myself. The only change was to substitute grips that better fit my small hand. Ive owned and let go of (through trades and whatnot) more K-Frame revolvers than I care to disclose. An object in motion tends to stay in motion; once it starts, the big .44 caliber cyclinder wants to keep on spinning. Yet still they have less that great SA triggers. I carried it until I bought a 686 when it came out. I retired as aFederal Det/Lt carrying a Sig P228. Due to its rust-resistant qualities, the Model 66 was even used by SEAL Team 6. Theyre a true shooters shooter. Most officers simply never fired enough rounds through their revolvers during their careers for this to be an issue. In fact, with the shrouded hammer and slimmed down profile, their 3 revolver is probably superior to a comparable S&W from any era for carry. I think weve all shot heavy triggers that kept on going smooth through the cycle, and lighter weight triggers that were gritty with multiple stops and stacks. The nickeled Model 19s were dropped from production in 1992. . Finally, they are not solid the slides have some slop in them and pistols rattle if you rap them with your hand or shake them. But if you want to become really proficient shooting this gun,the .38/.357 combo is the way you want to go. First of all a 5-inch barrel just looks beautiful. Second department we used .357 that were 125gr. The Model 19 Classic revolver features a handsome set of walnut grips, a 4.25 barrel, a black adjustable rear sight, and red ramp front sight. However, I know my way around Smith & Wesson revolvers and have been shooting them for more than 40 years. S&W Model 19 Classic vs Original hickok45 7.16M subscribers Subscribe 362K views 3 years ago Comparing the original "Classic" with the New "Classic." Original video with the old Model. Further, Ive noticed that on S&Ws webpage, they always depict the revolvers showing the right (non-hole) side of the weapon. Of course you should adjust for your round accordingly. Produced continuously from 1957 to 1999, tens of thousands of police officers carried a Model 19 on their hip, includingUS Immigration and Naturalization Service and the US Border Patrol agents. He was about to appear on a television show called You Asked for It, during which he would perform a fast-drawing act he was famous for. Hilary Hole. Awesome looking revolver, I have the new Colt King Cobra that I like and an old Model 15 Smith. There is just no comparison between the quality of the old guns and these newer ones. Because the .38 bullet spends something like twice the time in the barrel as the .357 bullet, the barrel rises more under recoil before the .38 bullet leaves the barrel than it does with .357 loads. So many guns, so little money! A Worthy Successor. THIS video is a follow-up from our fist video with this revolver. I think their appeal comes from the fact that you can see and actually feel the mechanics involved as you fire them. Grip: factory walnut (others available) If they lose that damn internal-lock, Ill consider them again, but not until. With only 60 rounds? There are a few current or recent production models here and there that have no lock (I believe a 686 is among them). 1,025.99 . smith & wesson / s&w and revolver model 19-5 excellent condition 4 inch " barrel ellicott city, md 21042: used: 8/1/2022: $899.99 .357 mag. Regardless what I shoot, the best I can do is to stay inside the 5 bullseye of a B-16 target at 25 yards. Firearm Specifications SKU: 12040 Model: Model 19 Classic Caliber: 357 Magnum 38 S&W SPECIAL P Capacity: 6 Hellstrom was the president of S&W at the time, and Jordan was famous for many reasons, including serving in the U.S. Border Patrol for 29 years and then touring the country for 11 years as a spokesman for the NRA, during which he performed trick-shooting exhibitions. Of course they are built like a tank and stand up to thousands of rounds of full power loads. The most obvious difference is the arched profile of the frame, at the hammer. We were later issued the stainless M-66 and were happy to move up to the vaunted .357 magnum. BE SURE to watch the Chapter 2 follow-up. In the meantime, give the Model 19 Classic a look. I own one of the new Colt 3 inch fixed sight revolvers it is a stainless steel copy of the old 3 in California Colt Python revolver and the last one I saw on one of my firearms auction catalogs went for $14,000.00 I paid a great deal less for my new Colt 3 inch fixed sight revolver and I was as happy as a little boy on Christmas morning. Then a couple of years later, I wised up and got an S&W 19 four inch and carried that until my wife bought me a Model 66 with a six inch barrel, the stainless version of the Model 19. I find them to carry better all day and be more nimble and quicker to get into action from a holster than the larger frame Smiths. It is a sleek, good looking, pistol with great lines and a blue finish. The deep illustrious bluing found on all of the Classic revolvers from Smith & Wesson is simply one-of-a-kind. It has been said of the k frame. You have some tough standards!:-). I guess, I think Ill somehow get into a 34 round gunfight someday. Something that pretty doesnt even have to work. I put 270 rounds of commercial .357 Magnum through the gun over four days of shooting. Yet the Rugers, with about the same weight and balance as the Smiths, tend to go for hundreds of thousands magnum loads, whereas the Smiths dont. After I was happy with my basic performance, it was off to the range. It made me realize how good I could actually shoot a pistol. $800-900. The K-frame is, IMO, the less desirable frame than the L frame in .357s when hurling the 158s downrange with a stout load of powder behind them. The solutions to the issues presented will be discussed in this article. There are countless instances where .38 Special simply cannot get the job done and one needs a round with far more penetration. Every thing you need in a fighting pistol and nothing you dont need. Estimated New and Used Values for a Smith & Wesson 586 Classic Values are based on a basic model with no options or colors. Regrettably, I now have to carry a semi-auto, and although I do well, I truly miss my Smith & Wesson revolvers. The workaround:shoot range sessions with .38 specials, carry .357 Magnums for hunting and self-defense. Chris Whisler writes . Accuracy was substandard compared to my older Smiths as well. But I still dont get it. I guess Im just maturity challenged. Not sure why the author feels it is slow. Even though this is a 4 pistol with square butt stocks, the frame has a round butt contour. What I cant decide is whether the Model 19 is $300 better than the Ruger. Unlike most of my reviews, I had to leave the gun idle for a couple of weeks between sessions, so I did a basic field cleaning at round 150 and a full detail strip and clean once I finished. I happen to think that a 5-inch barrel on a revolver might just be the perfect barrel length. Nice revolver and well written article, but until S&W gets rid of the wart on the side, the so called safety, Ill pass. BUT! Massad Ayoob (who has been an expert witness in many self-defensive shooting trials) recommends not removing the lock for this very reason. But when you despise the Hillary Hole that makes it a lot easier to consider a Kimber instead. Reliability * * * * * The Classic Model is finished in a nice blue that is close to the original guns. revolver on the big N-frame and had been doing so since 1935. The .357 cartridge was created by Winchester for S&W in the 1930's and used in the "N" frame S&W. GDHP and Agulias 158 gr. If youre talking about most commercial loads in a very short-barreled revolver, like a 2 1/2 snubby, this statement is true. Over time, using the .357 Magnum load, the temperature and pressure caused by these rounds will erode, cut into, and weaken the frame of the gun. That said, Ill NEVER relieve myself of any of my 19s. The Price for a Smith & Wesson 586 Classic has increased in cost by $0.00 in 2023 compared to 2022. Conclusion: Model 19 Review. They dont know anything about pinned and recessed target hammer, target trigger, target grips (3Ts). The Gold Dot averaged 1,372 fps while the Agulia load averaged 1,178 fps. Used that way, its highly unlikely the gun would experience any significant erosion or cracking. Due to its popularity, the Smith and Wesson Model 19 is often worth more than its suggested retail price. As I look back on it now, that was a foolish thing to do. Theres just no comparison. Taurus has redesigned this sporting pistol for performance. When engaged, it prevents the hammer from being cocked and the trigger from being squeezed. Caliber: .357 Magnum/.38 Special/.38 Special+P A thorough reading of the entire article will provide a clear . All the pivoting/bearing surfaces are smoothed up and polished, and the rebound spring is lightened by trimming a coil or so off of it. Back then we were required to qualify at 50 yards and this weapon never failed me. When everything is a game of compromises, the Model 19 was the first revolver to win that game, measuring weight against caliber in a perfect blend. Every group from all variety of ammo loads are smaller than 2 @25 yards and you were disappointed? K-Frame. PERIOD. Id take the 6-inch in stainless steel, though Ive always wanted a 4-inch too. Despite plenty of time on the range and a lotof time dry firing, I still cant shoot this gun fast. The chambers are not counterbored. It is narrower with beveled edges and a polished smooth trigger face, and. Yet the 9mm they have allowed to creep up more and more trying to get this cartridge to a decent level. They also allow for setting min cyl gap. If dirt gets in there, who knows if the gun will fire. Failure to fire twice. But there is nothing obligatory about the Lawyer Lock particularly in law. Find us on Hickok45 Twitter and Facebook, as well as "therealHickok45" on Instagram. Because of a scandium frame, it's a couple of ounces lighterslightly fewer than 36 ouncesthan the all-steel Model 19. In my view, S&W needs to reissue the Model 19/66s, only beefed up in the right parts, without turning the guns into boat anchors! So in 1975, my first Model 19 arrived with all the target goodie options. First time I took it to the range, it malfuctioned after maybe 30 magnum rounds. Burr maybe? I keep telling you folks that people are willing to pay for quality. Clearly, Im no Jerry Miculek. Never missed a beat with specials. I love the 19 more than anything and prize them, evwn over my new Sig P226, Mt25 Romeo, I will pick up next week when I get back home from a cruise. In S&W revolvers, what you want to ask a smith for is an action job. Kuhnhausen describes this a bit in his book. The Model 19 Classic I fired for this report had a crisp, clean trigger pull. On the range, the Classic 19 handled and shot as well as my older Model 19. Smith has also installed a ball/detent crane lock, and of course, the new 19 has the obligatory key lock. This is one place where this revolver absolutely shines. That was one of the places where I can certainly notice the difference between this gun and my Model 29. After a couple years of qualifying with the .357s the M-66s started to shake loose. With the right load a .30-30 can take deer out to 300 yards. My problem would be waiting for S&W to replace it! I will likely be forever conflicted about this gun. Eventually I ponied up the cash for a bull barreled PPC revolver to shoot the 1500 matches, but for a few years that Model 19 was the only arrow in my PPC quiver. Smith & Wesson Model 686 .357 Magnum/.38 S&W Special +P Revolver $ 919 99 919 dollars 99 cents. They provide a reduced profile but still allow for a full grip on the pistol. Ill try that and look for a burr. The same energy that started that big cylinder moving, continues to make it move. Awesome if you arent though, and glad your practice is paying off for you. Has that stupid lawyer lock which means these are hot garbage. Ive heard similar statements in the TTAG comment section and it seems to be a popular myth running around many forums. I started with .38 Special, moved to .38 Special +p, and ended up shooting regular magnum loads. Even with a six-inch barrel, the gun draws well and points even better. The little K frames are just about perfect for Law Enforcement use. They are worth a look and comparison no matter what the reason. And when the duty gun classes arrived, because some departments issued 4 Model 19s, a 4 Model 19 joined the fray. and of course, the new 19 has the obligatory key lock and that is the first thing going in the trash bin before I even shoot it! Of course they often come with outstanding grips that feel really nice. And give us the shining gems of the earlier days. . MIM parts I can deal with, Im a gunsmith by trade and know how to smooth the trigger up so that MIM parts are unnoticeable. The first Model 19 came off the production line in November of 1955, 65 years ago. They verified what I had already found searching the S&W forums: the top strap erosion and frame cracking was only an issue after firing thousands of rounds of .357. Both the 8 round Smith and the .45 Colt/ACP Rug er might be a bit bulky and heavy for CC, but both would make an excellent woods gun. Model 19 Classic. I dont know that I will indeed make it my EDC but I ordered a high quality 5 .357 last month to explore the idea. Try to get a gunsmith to remove the lock and they will decline because of liability concerns. A hit dead center is counterproductive if you spend extra time to get it. To me, it's a case of "you don't get a stupid lock, it's made in a period of better quality control and manufacturing, and it's less money." The single-action trigger pull averaged 4.0 pounds, 12.0 ounces with my RCBS trigger-pull scale, and the double-action pull was 13.0 pounds. You can also buy lighter rebound springs for the S&W. Loved my first Dan Wesson so much I had to get another one, Twins, Ruger Blackhawks .357 Mag 50th Anniversary Edition. 1. The Model 19 was also offered in nickel finish. It is a beautiful paperweight, though. Ill be checking out the best deal on the new 19 for sure! Introduced in the late 1950s, the Model 19 was the result of a collaborative effort between famed Border Patrol agent, gunfighter and author Bill Jordan and Smith & Wesson. From what Ive seen it seems that vented and non vented barrels are a wash in mid length barrels (a 5 Coonan generates velocities similar to a 5 revo lver) but the longer the bullet stays in the barrel the more is lost out the gap, so snubbies dont lose as much. That keeps the front end of the cylinder clean. Anything and everything to do with Revolvers. As far as accuracy, the Model 19 shot well. While purest will focus on the changes, I found myself appreciating how much that Smith actually got right. If you remove or modify the lock, then you are risking being demonized by an anti-gun DA if you ever find yourself in court after a defensive shooting. The Model 19 Classic uses the K/L/N-Frame rounded grip frame that all S&W revolvers currently use. When I get a Smith, maybe Ill be looking at a used model. Gone are the old-style cylinder locking lug that was pinned into the barrel lug and the hollow ejector rod. Open the cylinder and check to see if the extractor rod has come slightly unscrewed? When I bought my .30-30 I thought about going with a .44magnum but while the right load will produce more energy, that advantage is gone by 75 yards. The flat part of your forcing cone is normal for this revolver and is one of the reasons the guns fail when one puts a steady diet of .357s through their guns. Then I add one or two more targets at various distances but none more than seven yards and practice fast transitions from target to target. Thanks for a wheel gun article. It was an immensely powerful and popular revolver, but it was heavy. The new model also has an un-serrated back strap. The Model 19 Classic revolver features a handsome set of walnut grips, a 4.25 barrel, a black adjustable rear sight, and red ramp front sight. The suggested retail price for the firearm ranges from $599 to $669. I agree with JWT regarding barrel length and DG regarding quality. You put a bullet in it and it goes bang. He claimed thatwith todays modern loads, the .357 Magnum offersrelatively little stopping power improvementover the 9mm+P. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Until this lock is removed I would not bet my life on a S&W with the lock! The only reliable gun safety is between the shooters ears. My ugly Glocks sit at my bedside. Range work always brings out things that are not readily noticeable from a cursory examination. History has shown that the K frame does not hold up well under a steady diet of magnum loads. Rather than shoot .38 special, I would rather shoot .357 loaded down to .38 velocities. Beyond .357 Magnum caliber and affordability, the Model 19sergonomics was the key to its popularity. Smith & Wesson was manufacturing its .357 Mag. Overall * * * * so check Salt N Pepa Jacket which is a most selling outfit in our store, Shop now and get amazing discounts and offers. Ships To Store. As far as my high school pistol team, no we did not have one. True, and Im not much of a fan of the 1-7/8 rev olver. She hates autos. Guns were offered with either a square butt or a round butt, depending on barrel length. The .357 definitely benefits from room to run, even more so in a lever gun. These are both polymer frame one being a hammer fired DA/SA and the latter single stage striker fiire meaning the striker is fully cooked by the slide cycle not trigger pull. In my eyes, it's one of the sexiest revolvers ever made. I DO realize theres some cost savings, but is it really worth it? $969.00 . Agreed to this day based on FBI shooting data no other normally carried SD or LE duty cartdige comes close to the one shot stop data of the full power 357 loaded with 125gr JHP of old. Free shipping on many items | Browse your favorite brands | affordable prices. Why not bring back the Model 28? All the way out to 100 yards, they are only 3.6 apart, if the gun is zeroed at 25 yards. Two-handed, it gave me plenty of real estate for an absolutely rock-solid hold on the mid-framed Magnum. Model 19 Classic Smith & Wesson hickok45 7.16M subscribers Subscribe 253K views 4 years ago Shooting and discussing the new S&W Model 19 Classic. The Model 19 Classic weighs 37.2 ounces and is 9.9 inches long and 5.8 inches high. I enjoyed it, and that is a beautiful revolver. breadcrumb. K-Frame. eBay; smith wesson model 19; smith wesson model 19. Related Tags: Longer bullets are guided by the cylinder throat and thus are not impacting the lower barrel throat as with shorter bullets. Speers .38 +P 125 grain Gold Dot was very controllable at a mild 888 fps. Model 15s, 13s, 19s, 586s, 27s, 28s and 29s. As the law enforcement community transitioned to semi-auto pistols, the demand for the Combat Magnum waned. It also featured a fully shrouded ejection rod, a heavy barrel profile, a Baughman ramped front sight, and a fully micrometer adjustable rear sight. Compare. Caliber: 357 Magnum, .38 Special; Capacity: 6 I prefer the new Colt King Cobra instead. As time progressed, Smith & Wesson looked for ways to reduce the manufacturing cost of the Model 19 and 66. 4.5 (54) Smith & Wesson Model 642 .38 Special +P Revolver . There are even some exceptions where collectors have paid over $2000 for this revolver. And then, because this is grumbly bear country and I cant handle the recoil of an N frame in .44 Magnum, a Model 66 came along. I would keep working with it. And as far as the forcing cones are concerned, Ive never found out why S&W forcing cones on K-frames erode so much with magnum loads, and yet the cones of similar size in Ruger Security-Sixes dont. Jordan believed that a medium-size double-action revolver with a 4.0-inch heavy barrel chambered for the .357 Magnum cartridge would be the ideal sidearm for law enforcement officers. The only place Ive been able to get any is through buying 10-20 boxes online, and even then its difficult to know what one is getting or how effective it is. Using a wide variety of ammunition, none of my five-shot groups shot from a sandbag were larger than two inches at 25 yards. I should have bought onethen. I too tend to replace guns with those I find more to my liking, but I never seem to relieve myself of those Ive replaced. I felt well armed with either. 5 more deals from grabagun.com . A high quality .357 Magnum revolver with a 5-inch barrel (starts daydreaming about it). The new revolvers sound tempting, but theres that Hillary Hole that S&W persists in forcing on us. Be patient and look for a nice example of both, and hang onto them. Build Learn more MSRP: $ 1289.00 SKU: 12039 357 Magnum Caliber 6 Rounds Capacity K-Frame Frame Size Weight: 34.2 oz. Ive never cleaned a gun Ive reviewed before before, but I felt duty bound to put this one back in same shape in which I got it.
Is Griffpatch On The Scratch Team, Jake Smith White Buffalo Military, Uvalde County Elections 2020 Results, Needle Proof Gloves For Police, 3,000 Bushel Grain Bin Dimensions, Articles S